The resignation lands on a Tuesday morning. A senior engineer, three years in, has a competing offer at a 35% premium. By Thursday, a counteroffer is on the table. By the following Monday, the employee has agreed to stay.
H2: Why Indian HR Teams Reach For The Counteroffer
Attrition in India has eased from pandemic-era peaks but still carries meaningful cost. Aon’s Annual Salary Increase and Turnover Survey 2025-26 India pegs overall attrition at 16.2% in 2025, down from 17.7% in 2024 and the 21.4% peak in 2022. India’s large IT services firms sit lower today, with TCS at 13.5%, Infosys at 12.3%, and Wipro at 14.2% voluntary attrition on a trailing twelve-month basis.
H3: Do Counteroffers Actually Keep People?
SHRM’s 2025 Benchmarking Report puts average non-executive cost per hire at $5,475, with executive hires running close to seven times higher. Add in six to nine months of lost productivity, interim coverage, and institutional knowledge walking out of the building, and a one-time 20% salary bump looks like the cheaper line item. That math drives the reflex. It also hides the deeper diagnostic question that should come first: why so many counteroffers end in a second resignation within the year.
H4: When A Counteroffer Can Work, And When It Won’t
Specific conditions make a counter genuinely viable. The employee flagged an internal pay gap in the last twelve months, and nothing changed. The internal band is genuinely stale against current benchmarks. The role, manager and growth path still work for the person, and the external offer is primarily a salary jump rather than a bid attached to a richer rewards package.
H5: Where A Counter Has A Real Chance
Counters rarely rescue an exit rooted in manager friction, stalled progression or burnout. If the resignation conversation keeps circling “growth,” “respect,” “balance,” or “team dynamics,” money is treating a symptom.
H6: Practical Framework
Before a counteroffer leaves HR’s desk, run a diagnostic sweep on every case. Each filter calls for a conversation, not a form field. Together they decide whether the organisation is retaining a valued contributor or paying a premium to delay the inevitable.
| Filter | What To Check | What It Decides |
| Root cause | Is the primary driver pay, growth, manager quality or wellbeing? | Whether money is even the right lever |
| Market reality | Is the internal band genuinely below current benchmarks? | Whether the counter closes a real gap or masks one |
List
- Item 1
- Item 2
